Products
Every squishy is a surprise — choose your size and we'll pick something amazing for you.
Mystery
Large Mystery Squishy
The perfect starter mystery! Palm-sized, slow-rising, and super cute. Great for desks, bags, and gifting.
Fan Fave
Medium Mystery Squishy
Our fan-favorite size. Satisfying to squeeze, beautifully detailed — perfect for collectors and stress relief.
Best Value
Small Mystery Squishy
Go big! Large squishies have more detail, more texture, and a bigger unboxing wow-factor.
Premium
XL Mystery Squishy
The showstopper. XL squishies are jumbo-sized, ultra-soft, and exclusively feature our rarest designs.
- Free Shipping $35+
- Ships in 1–2 Business Days
- 4.9-Star Average Rating
- 100% Secure Checkout
- Every Order Packed With Care
What Our Customers Say
Real reviews from real squishy lovers — unedited and honest.
I ordered the medium mystery squishy not knowing what to expect and got the most adorable strawberry cat I've ever seen. It's SO soft and slow-rising, exactly as described. Already ordered two more for gifts. 10/10 would recommend to literally everyone.
I keep one on my desk now. The slow-rising foam is incredibly satisfying — way better quality than I expected for the price. Got a rare unicorn design and my coworkers all want one now. Shipping was super fast too, arrived in 4 days.
Ordered the XL and got one of the rare exclusive designs. It's huge, incredibly detailed, and feels premium. The packaging was cute too — felt like a real unboxing experience. My daughter and I both squealed. Already planning my next order!
Ordered a mix of small and medium for my kid's birthday party favors. Every single one was different, adorable, and excellent quality. Parents were asking me where I got them. Will 100% be a repeat customer. Thank you Mystery Squishy!
I've been collecting squishies for years and this is my new favorite way to get them. The surprise factor makes it SO much more exciting than just buying one you know. Got a kawaii avocado one and a ghost one. Both are squeezable perfection.
Ordered the large mystery squishy for my daughter who's been asking for squishies for months. When she opened it and found a big smiley cloud design, she was over the moon. High quality, no smell, very soft. Already planning to order more.